
I first made these eyeball meatballs two years ago on a whim, and now it’s not Halloween in our house without them. The kids start asking about “eyeball spaghetti” the minute the pumpkins come out.
Here’s why I love it: it’s just spaghetti and meatballs. Nothing fancy, nothing you have to hunt down. A little fresh mozzarella and a slice of black olive turn a normal weeknight dinner into something the whole table gets excited about. And on a night when everyone’s running on candy and costumes, it’s nice to get a real meal in them first.
It’s also a great one to make with your kids. Little hands are perfect for rolling meatballs and placing the “pupils.”
Updated October 2026 with fresh mozzarella eyeballs, make-ahead and gluten-free tips, and answers to the questions you’ve sent me.

Yes. Roll and bake the meatballs up to two days ahead and keep them in the fridge. On Halloween, warm them in a 350°F oven for about 10 minutes, then add the mozzarella and olives and melt for 2 to 3 minutes. You can also freeze the baked meatballs (without cheese) for up to three months.
Easy swaps: use gluten-free breadcrumbs (or ¾ cup almond flour) in the meatballs and your favorite gluten-free spaghetti. Most jarred marinaras, including Rao’s, don’t contain gluten, but always check the label.
Mom tip: want extra veggies in there? Blend a handful of fresh spinach into the sauce before you heat it. Nobody at my table has ever noticed.
I’m not a gory-decor person, so I keep it cozy and just a little spooky. The skull platter does most of the work. Everything else is warm and neutral: a gingham tablecloth, a floral tea towel, a wicker chair and a loaf of crusty bread on a wood board. For more ideas, here’s how I do simple Halloween decor around the rest of the house.

Bonus! Want to complete your spooky tablescape? Comment below with “HALLOWEEN” and I’ll share some of my favourite Halloween serving dishes and decorating ideas! Use code SHELLEY to receive 15% off of your Geometry order.
Sliced black olives. Kalamata halves work if you want them bigger, and a dot of pesto under the olive gives you “green eyes.”
Fresh mozzarella. It melts into a soft white dome that actually looks like an eyeball. Save the parmesan for sprinkling on top.
About 12 to 14 two-inch meatballs, enough for a family of four to five.
Absolutely. Bake them according to the package, then add the mozzarella and olives at the end. Halloween night is not the night to be a hero.
If you make these, tag me @house_and_roam_. I love seeing your eyeball creations. And if you’re looking at your dining room thinking it needs more than a skull platter, that’s what I’m here for. My e-design service is $595 a room, or we can talk it through on a 60-minute, $100 design call, virtual or in person in San Antonio.
Happy haunting (and happy eating),
Shelley xx
We may earn a small commission for products from the companies mentioned in this post. However, our recommendations are based on quality and alignment with mindful decorating principles. Contact House & Roam today and schedule a consultation with one of our talented interior designers. Let’s transform your living space into a masterpiece of Balancing Beauty and Functionality. Subscribe here to our weekly newsletter for VIP sales events, design inspo and more!
